As I’ve discussed in
several past articles, the popular belief that you must eat a high
protein diet if you are trying to lose weight fast has got to be
one of the biggest misconceptions in
the weight loss industry.
Well, here’s even
more proof that
when it comes to burning body fat, a high protein diet is not necessary.
Now, before I share with you the results of these two studies, I have
to be honest with you and say that I’m very careful in how I read and
interpret many of these studies.
The problem is that most studies are done on individuals that don’t
weight train in any manner.
So, as soon as you put them on a weight loss / fat burning workout they
drop a lot of body weight fast.
The problem with those studies is that when you take any individual
that normally isn’t very physically active, and all of a sudden you
place them on a workout program several days a week, regardless of what
type of workout, they will indeed lose weight initially.
So, it’s not necessarily the workout plan that was the key to the
weight loss, but in fact the simple fact that they increased their
physical activity.
That’s why you have to be careful when reading these studies.
However, what’s excellent about the two studies that I’m going to share
with you here is that they were done on individuals that are very
active, as a matter of fact they were done on
competitive athletes.
These studies were performed
to find
out if a high protein diet had any effect on their body composition.
This would be interesting for you if you are looking to burn fat and
tone up (…which if you’re reading this article and my site, then
obviously you are).
In this study they took 23 college athletes that were experienced
weight trainers.
They were placed on a 12 week, 4 days a week workout program.
They were divided into 3 groups:
1) Those that ate a low protein diet
2) Those that ate a typical protein diet (1.8 grams /kg of bodyweight)
3) Those that ate a slightly higher protein diet (2 grams/kg of
bodyweight)
Everyone ate an amount of calories that was less than what their body
needed per day.
In other words, they were in a “calorie deficit” (as I’ve written a lot
about).
Well, at the end of the 12 weeks they measured their body composition,
meaning they measured how much body fat they had versus how much lean
muscle mass they possesed.
The result?
No significant
differences in body composition was measured between any of the 3
groups!
Did you get that?
That means that
those that ate a low
protein diet burned just as much body fat and gained just as much lean
muscle mass as the group that ate a high protein diet.
Eating a diet high
in protein was of no advantage whatsoever in their body
compositions.
Another study had the exact results:
They took 15 young men who weight trained and performed cardio for an
hour and a half, 3 times a week.
They also placed all of the groups in a calorie deficit, but with one
eating a low amount of protein and the other on a higher protein
diet…….total calories being the same.
At the end of the study there was also
no difference in body composition between the high or low protein group.
Again,
eating a high protein diet had
no special effect……as most diet books and websites would like
you to believe.
So, the next time someone tries to get you to buy their protein powder
or bars, or suggests that you must be eating a high amount of protein
if you want to lose weight, you’ll know that it’s nothing but a popular
myth.
As I’ve been writing all along,
it’s
what type of calories you’re eating, it’s how many calories you’re
eating……period!
Sincerely,
Jonathan Perez
Cleveland Firefighter
Certified ACE / IAFF / IAFC Firefighter Peer Fitness Trainer
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jonathan Perez has
written many articles exposing the many weight loss programs and diet
myths
being spread about in the bodybuilding / fitness industry and on the
internet.
His eBook,
"Fat To Buff!", has
helped many overweight individuals lose weight and burn body fat by
detailing the workout program strategies and eating
techniques that
actually work
at losing weight and building lean muscle tissue.
Many of Jonathan's other articles are located at
www.FatToBuff.com/articles.html.
His main website is located at
www.FatToBuff.com.